Signal

Why 76% of Our Applicants Are Rejected

Why 76% of Our Applicants Are Rejected

We get asked this a lot: "Why do so many people apply, but so few get in?"

The truth is simple: 76% of applications don't make it through. And that's not a bug—it's how we keep the community sharp, focused, and aligned.

The Application Process

When you apply, you're asked a few precise questions. We're not testing your writing skills. We're looking for something deeper:

  • Clarity – Do you really know what you're building, or are you still figuring it out?
  • Execution – Have you taken real steps already, or is it still just an idea?
  • Consistency – Do you have a track record of following through?
  • Leverage – What's the unique perspective or strength you bring to the table?

We read every application carefully. And believe me—it's pretty easy to spot when someone's not ready yet.

Why Most Don't Get In

If your application doesn't make it, chances are it fell into one of these buckets:

  • Too vague → "I want to be successful" isn't enough. We need to see direction.
  • All talk, no action → Big dreams are great, but we look for proof that you've started.
  • Chasing shortcuts → If you're just looking for a quick hack, this isn't the right place.
  • Different priorities → Sometimes people are smart and driven—but not aligned with the values of the circle.

It's not about being "good" or "bad". It's about fit.

The 24% Who Make It

Those who are accepted aren't superheroes. They just show a few clear signs:

  • They know what they want.
  • They've already started doing the work.
  • They think long-term.
  • They want to contribute as much as they get.

When those signals show up, it's easy to say yes.

What Rejection Really Means

Being rejected doesn't mean you're not talented. It usually just means you're not ready yet.

We've seen plenty of people come back stronger—clearer, more focused, with more proof of execution—and then get accepted on a second try.

So if you don't get in the first time, don't sweat it. Take the feedback, sharpen your answers, keep building, and reapply.

Closing Thoughts

So, why are 76% rejected? Because we're looking for alignment, not perfection.

If you're serious, stay consistent, keep building, and when you apply again—make sure your answers reflect who you really are and where you're going.

We'd love to see you in the 24%.